MN Legislative Issues and Bills 2023
Issues and potential bills happen so fast that it is often difficult to keep up. We do our best to keep you informed of bills affecting our children so that you can submit public comment and contact legislators. When possible, the information will include bill numbers. HF=House file; SF=Senate file.
- HF 146 – SF 63
Out-of-state haven for minor gender hormones & sex change
[This bill creates a haven for a parent/guardian to bring a child to Minnesota for “gender affirming” care including puberty blockers and sex change procedures, regardless of the other parent’s wishes or court ordered protections from another state – no extradition, no parental rights.]
- HF 1 – SF 1
Allows abortion up to birth PASSED
- HF 91 – SF 70
Repeals medical protections for infants who survive abortions
- HF 174 – SF 662
Comprehensive Sex Ed mandate (Information on CPL website from 2019)
- HF 320 – SF 619
Authorizes state SEL standards and establishes Ethnic Studies
- HF 16 – SF 23
Prohibits talk therapy for gender issues for minors
- HF 951 (no Senate file yet)
Same as HF16
- HF1269 – SF1311
Ethnic Studies and Home School issues
- HF 367 – SF 610
Removes vaccine exemptions in child care facilities and family child care providers
- HF 8 – SF56
State grants to schools for student “comprehensive” health services. Over $200M appropriated.
- HF 173 – SF 37
Constitutional amendment for equal rights for LGBTQ+
- HF 407 (no Senate file yet)
Same as HF173
- HF 353 – SF 76
Parents’ Bill of Rights
- HF 242 (no Senate file yet)
Constitutional amendment extends state authority over nonpublic schools (“achievement standards for all children,”) transfers authority for education from the legislature to the “state.” [Information on CPL website from 2019)
- HF 905 – SF 836
Allows minors age 16 or older to consent to gender health services without parental consent
- HF 426 – F 311
Prohibits boys in girls’ private facilities; prohibits girls in boys’ private facilities
- HF 432 – SF2627
Increases penalties for dealing in child porn
- HF 549 – SF 734
Parental curriculum review and consent for sexual education curriculum
- SF 933 (no House file yet)
Prohibits minors at drag performances
Find your legislators at Who represents me?
- CPL Focused MN Legislation 2022
- CPL Focused MN Legislation 2020
- CPL Focused MN Legislation 2019
- CPL Focused MN Legislation 2016
Title IX Sex Discrimination Rules
Title IX of the 1972 Education Amendments was written to ensure that “no person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.” The US Department of Education appears set to use Title IX as the legal authority for creating a new prohibition against discrimination on the basis of “gender identity.” Draft Policy (regulation begins on page 651).
Child Protection League joined a coalition of 27 organizations through Parents Defending Education to send a letter to Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona expressing concerns with a forthcoming rewrite of Title IX sex discrimination rules. Coalition Letter (PDF)
SAVE also has an extensive list of the attorneys general, lawmakers, organizations, and commentators who have come out in opposition to the draft policy. CPL signed on to this list as well.
The Church and Politics: What Ministers and Churches Can Do to Affect Public Policy (PDF)
Church leaders who want to educate their members about civic issues, particular legislation and viewpoints, may be receiving false information from activist groups who are attempting to silence them with threats of losing tax-exempt status. Equip your church leaders with this important legal background from The Pacific Justice Institute.
School Boards are the Front Lines
School boards are often the gate keepers for the school districts. The new strategy of those pushing radical agendas to “fundamentally transform our nation” is to do so locally, through our children. Local community leaders are often hostile to the values and virtues of the family. Parents are beginning to rise up! They want reading, writing and arithmetic – not lessons on Critical Race Theory, Equity, gender identity, to name a few.
Learn ways you and your community can make a difference at the school board level!
Go to School Boards—The Key
Protection of Pupil Rights
The Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, is an open access to law website. This US code protects the rights of students in conjunction with parents. As we battle for parental rights, this code may be of importance. 20 U.S. Code § 1232h
Did you know that the school districts across the country received “Covid 19 Relief” funding? How was this money distributed? Read Covid Relief Funding Streams for School Districts for how these Billion+ dollars went!
Critical Race Theory (CRT) and Equity
Schools are integrating Critical Race Theory (CRT) into all aspects of curriculum, even math! Is your child being exposed at school to this detrimental theory? According to Britannica, CRT is the view that race, instead of being biologically grounded and natural, is socially constructed and that race, as a socially constructed concept, functions as a means to maintain the interests of the white population that constructed it.Read more details on this hot topic at Critical Race Theory and Equity.
Racial Quotas in School Discipline
Overview: Minnesota is full steam ahead implementing the racial quotas in school discipline in schools throughout the state.
History: Upon recommendation of the Federal Commission studying school safety, acting U.S. Attorney General Whitaker rescinded the Obama-era “Racial Equity in School Discipline” directive that disregarded federal law and subjected public school students to two-tiered discipline based on race. However, the Dayton administration anticipated this sea change and initiated its own racial equity directive. In October of 2017, the MN Department of Human Rights (MDHR) sent a letter to 43 school districts informing them that they have a “racial discipline disparity” in violation of the MN Human Rights Act. Unless they entered into a “settlement agreement” with the state, they would file charges and investigate them for civil rights violations.
Read Minnesota Goes Full Radical on Race Based School Discipline.
MN State High School League (MSHSL) Transgender Policy
The issue of transgender was addressed by the MSHSL in 2014 which, as predicted, opened the door for girls’ sports teams to biological males. The Child Protection League was active in sounding the alarm. Take a look at the ads CPL produced that are just as relevant today and read the history about this policy at MSHSL Transgender Policy.
Data Collecting and Opt Outs
In addition to data collecting, parents should be aware of the dangers of the Internet especially now that children as young as 5 are using iPads and Chromebooks in school. See our sections on Internet Safety for Children and EBSCO, GALE and MN ELibrary for helps to monitor and keep your child safe.
What About Privacy Laws? What you need to know.
- The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) was originally a strong bill that blocked any school from disclosing Personally Identifiable Information (PII) from a student’s educational records to any non-school official without parental notification or consent.
- In 2008 and 2009 the bill was amended and consequently left useless by allowing schools to share data with third party companies and organizations.
- Medical and counseling records included in your child’s education records are not protected by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA).
- The Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (PPRA) protects students from having to reveal personal information without parental consent IF it is required, funded by the federal government, and collects data such as political affiliations and religious beliefs.
- Most surveys given to students are NOT required and therefore are not protected by PPRA.
- Schools are only required to notify parents of a survey being given and allow parents to opt their children out.
- Schools often slip this information in with multiple forms or handbooks in the beginning of the year to meet federal requirements and often goes unnoticed by parents.
- PPRA gives you the right to stop the data mining of your child, but you have to enforce it.
Excerpt from page 6 of Data Mining Your Child (PDF)
The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) and
The Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (PPRA)
FERPA, a federal privacy law, that afforded parents the right to:
- Have access to their children’s education records,
- Confirm the accuracy and seek to have the records amended,
- Review and appeal the information, and
- Consent to the disclosure of personally identifiable information
What Is FERPA (PDF), provided by the Capitol Resource Institute, explains what each of these rights meant. the newer PPRA amendment protects against data that isn’t required. You may have to be diligent in seeking to opt your child out of these surveys. Often data mining is part of the Social Emotional Learning curriculum. The Data Mining Your Child (PDF) guidebook explains how to opt out of these in-class invasive surveys.
Have you ever wondered what EdTech apps your student is required to use at school and what information is collected and shared? The Student Data Privacy Project is addressing this issue by providing parents with sample templates and letters so that you can request your child’s data from their school.
More Privacy Issue Information
- School Counselors – Sources of Indoctrination
The American School Counselor Association (ASCA) trains school counselors to hide students’ sex and gender preferences from parents. What you can do.
- Do not allow your child to have any sessions with school counselors without your presence
- Fill out the 3-day demand form to ensure your participation in your child’s wellbeing.
Read more in Behind Closed Doors, School Counselors are not the ones you grew up trusting (PDF).
- Social and Emotional Learning (SEL) Data Collection
Each child’s responses are collected in a “data dashboard” and measured to see whether the child demonstrates change in regard to attitudes, feelings and behaviors. The results are entered into a national SEL data bank, often to 3rd party vendors. Find additional information under Social and Emotional Learning.
- Data Mining Your Children
Another good article Data Mining Your Children (PDF) is as relevant today as it was in 2014 when it was written.
- FOIA/Open Records Requests
It is your right to view public records. If you are having difficulty being allowed to see school records such as the surveys given to your child, the curriculum used, etc., submit what is called an Open Records or Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request. Use these links to help you with the process….
- Do you know your rights?
Take the Parental Rights quiz How Well Do You Know Your Rights?
- Minnesota Student Survey
Did you know that there is an invasive survey that the schools administer every three years to students that ask intimate questions of your child? The test is administered January to June.OPT OUT your children from this Minnesota Student Survey!
The Minnesota Student Survey is run by a partnership of four state agencies: the Minnesota Departments of Education, Health, Public Safety, and Human Services. Read our 2022 CPL Article about these surveys then go to the Minnesota 2022 Student Survey site for contact information. The survey is voluntary but who makes that decision – you need to let them know NO for your child.
Do you trust the schools with intimate details about your child? Read the “versions that are available to review” below to see what kind of questions they ask—read to the very end!
- Keep Your Children Home on the Day of Silence
Each year, usually in April, schools across the country allow students and teachers to refuse to speak all day. The Day of Silence is a tool of the Gay Lesbian Straight Education Network (GLSEN) to force all school children, their parents, teachers and administrators to support and affirm this ideology by remaining silent. By refusing to speak, they marginalize those who disagree.
• A Day of Silence?
• The ‘Day of Silence’ Walk Out
Is Your Child Unsafe at the Doctor’s Office? Invasive Teen Questionnaire
The HealthPartner’s policy is one of many who are now requiring clinicians to administer a pre-teen/teen invasive health questionnaire answered only by the adolescent. The parent is then asked to leave the child alone with the clinician so the clinician can engage the child “one-on-one” about the answers and personal concerns. Plus with whom is this data being shared? State law allows the Minnesota Department of Health to require providers and health plans to “provide patient health records and claim files” M.S. 62J.321 Data Collection & Processing Procedures. Please read the following for details so you can protect your child!
• Is Your Child Unsafe at the Doctor’s Office?
• Questionnaire (PDF)
• Letter: Parents beware of new health survey (PDF)
• When the Sign Says “No Parents Allowed”
Beware of doctors that won’t let you as a parent accompany your child to the clinical area. The HIPPA Privacy Act is supposed to protect us from tyranny or any unethical deeds done by doctors and any other outside parties. It is absurd to think that a child’s privacy is being violated by having their own parent with them.
Comprehensive Sexual Health Education (CSE) and Your Rights as a Parent
Attention Parents: SIECUS and Planned Parenthood are trying to MANDATE Comprehensive Sex Education (CSE) through legislation in MN and throughout the nation. If the CSE bill passes in the 2020 MN session, every school will be required to teach CSE from K-12 in all public and charter schools. Read more and stay informed at Stop Comprehensive Sex Education (CSE)
You have a legal right to know what health curriculum and resources your school is using. Please check with your own school. Look at the list of Prominent CSE curricula. Many have been surprised to learn that their own schools have already adopted CSE curriculum. Take it before other parents, your school administrators and your school boards if necessary. CSE is not a state mandate…yet. You still have a voice and you still have parental rights in directing the education of your children. It’s up to you.
Parental Non-Consent Form
This form prepared by The Liberty Council law firm, Lynchburg, VA, may be used by Minnesota parents in their local schools concerning curriculum that they object to. The purpose of this form is to put the school on notice regarding what is/is not acceptable for your child and that you must be provided preemptive notice. The introductory letter explains how to use this form and recommends that you fill one out for each of your children. Liberty Council states that they are prepared to assist and provide guidance in this area.
- Liberty Council Introductory Letter (PDF)
- Parental Non-Consent Form (PDF)
- Parental Non-Consent Form (RTF format)
- Link to MN law 120A
- Link to MN law 120B.20
With the ever-expanding use of CSE in schools, it is important for you to know what the Minnesota state law currently states.
MN law 120A.22, Subdivion 1
The parent of a child is primarily responsible for assuring that the child acquires knowledge and skills that are essential for effective citizenship.
MN law 120B.20
Each school district shall have a procedure for a parent, guardian, or an adult student, 18 years of age or older, to review the content of the instructional materials to be provided to a minor child or to an adult student and, if the parent, guardian, or adult student objects to the content, to make reasonable arrangements with school personnel for alternative instruction. Alternative instruction may be provided by the parent, guardian, or adult student if the alternative instruction, if any, offered by the school board does not meet the concerns of the parent, guardian, or adult student. The school board is not required to pay for the costs of alternative instruction provided by a parent, guardian, or adult student. School personnel may not impose an academic or other penalty upon a student merely for arranging alternative instruction under this section. School personnel may evaluate and assess the quality of the student’s work.
Gender & Privacy Policies
The gender ideology is now creeping into our schools indoctrinating our children even at the elementary level. What is the pronoun mandate? Are our children safe when male students can use female restrooms and locker rooms because the male student decides he now identifies as a female despite his male biological body? Be aware of what is occurring in your schools and communities that embrace this dangerous new trend.
- The “Toolkit” Agenda
Despite strong opposition, the Toolkit to Ensure Safe and Supportive Schools for Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Students was passed in MN by an unelected, governor appointed Minnesota Department of Education committee. It’s not just about bathrooms and locker rooms. It’s about indoctrination into a dangerous gender ideology. The pronoun mandate is the most dangerous part of the Toolkit. Use this extensive resource to educate yourself on the issues.
- A Critical Review of Schools In Transition: A Guide for Supporting Transgender Students in K-12 Schools (PDF)
Radical gender activist groups such as the National Center for Lesbian Rights, Gender Spectrum, and the LGBT & HIV Project have published this guidebook, Schools in Transition (PDF), for schools across the country to use in setting school policies that endorse and promote transgender ideology. The MN Department of Education (MDE) recommends this guidebook as a credible resource.
- Governor Doubling Down on Obama Transgender Policy
President Trump withdrew the Obama administration’s threat to withhold federal funding if schools don’t comply with gender inclusive policies, however; the MN governor and the Department of Education are exerting pressure on districts to adopt the now-rescinded policy. Will the new MN governor follow suit?
- Title IX Dear Colleague Letter (PDF)
Alliance Defending Freedom refutes the U.S. Departments of Education and Justice issued “Dear Colleague” Letter claiming that Title IX requires every school district to treat students consistent with their gender identity.
- U.S. Department of Education Confirms Title IX Protects Students from Discrimination Based on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity
As of June 16, 2021, the Department of Education in this current administration has reinterpreted Title IX to mean sex to include sexual orientation and gender identity. Notice it is an interpretation and not law. This means that women’s’ bathrooms are open to boys who “identify as women” in our schools.
- 6 Myths About Allowing Transgender Students to Use Restrooms of the Opposite Sex
Distinguishes between the facts and the myths in the law.
- Disturbing Video Shows Risk to Girls and Women Posed by Co-Ed Restrooms and Locker Rooms